Home / Blog / AccessiBe vs Manual Remediation

AccessiBe vs manual remediation: why overlays don't work

Accessibility overlays promise ADA compliance for $49/month. The FTC, courts, and disability advocates all say otherwise. Here's what the data shows.

The overlay track record in 2025:

$1,000,000 — FTC fine against accessiBe for deceptive compliance claims

22.6% — of ADA web lawsuits in H1 2025 targeted sites already using an overlay

0% — reduction in lawsuit frequency for overlay users vs non-users

70+ — disability advocacy organizations that oppose overlay widgets

What are accessibility overlays?

Accessibility overlays (also called widgets or toolbars) are JavaScript plugins that add a floating button to your website. When clicked, they open a panel with options like "increase font size," "high contrast mode," or "screen reader mode." Popular overlay products include accessiBe, UserWay, EqualWeb, and AudioEye's widget.

The pitch is simple: add one line of code, get instant ADA compliance. The reality is far more complicated.

Why overlays don't provide ADA compliance

Overlays fail for a fundamental technical reason: they inject JavaScript on top of your existing code, but they can't change the underlying HTML structure. Screen readers interact directly with your DOM — not the overlay's JavaScript layer. If your HTML has missing alt text, broken ARIA attributes, or unlabeled form fields, the overlay can't fix those problems for assistive technology users.

Specifically, overlays cannot fix:

Broken heading hierarchy

Screen readers use heading levels (H1–H6) to navigate. Overlays can't restructure your HTML.

Missing form labels

If an input lacks a programmatic label, the overlay can guess — often incorrectly.

Keyboard traps

If a modal or dropdown traps focus, the overlay can't fix the event handlers.

Complex ARIA patterns

Custom widgets (tabs, accordions, date pickers) need correct ARIA roles, states, and properties baked into the code.

Document structure

Landmarks, regions, and reading order are determined by HTML structure, not JavaScript injection.

Dynamic content

Single-page apps, AJAX-loaded content, and infinite scroll break overlay detection.

The FTC fine and what it means

In 2025, the Federal Trade Commission settled with accessiBe for $1 million over claims that its overlay widget could make websites ADA compliant. The FTC found that accessiBe's marketing was deceptive — the product did not deliver the compliance it promised.

This matters because it establishes at the federal level that overlay widgets are not considered a valid compliance solution. If the company selling the overlay admits (via settlement) that it can't guarantee compliance, you can't rely on it to protect you from a lawsuit.

What actually works: scanning + code-level fixes

Real ADA compliance requires changing your actual HTML, CSS, and JavaScript. The process is:

1. Scan — Identify every WCAG violation on your site with an automated scanner. This gives you the exact elements, selectors, and criteria that are failing.

2. Prioritize — Fix critical and serious issues first. These are the violations most likely to appear in a lawsuit: missing alt text, low contrast, unlabeled forms, empty links.

3. Fix — Apply code-level changes. Good scanners provide the exact corrected markup — not just "add alt text" but the actual HTML diff you need to apply.

4. Monitor — Set up ongoing scans to catch regressions. Every content update, plugin install, or theme change can reintroduce violations.

Cost comparison: overlays vs real remediation

Overlay widget

Fixes code: No · Legal protection: No

22%+ get sued anyway

$49–$490/yr

Scanner + DIY fixes

Fixes code: Yes · Legal protection: Yes

Addresses actual code issues

$0–$348/yr

Scanner + dev help

Fixes code: Yes · Legal protection: Yes

Handles complex issues too

$348/yr + $500–$1,500

The overlay is cheaper upfront but provides no actual protection. Real scanning and remediation costs roughly the same annually and actually fixes the problems.

Switching from an overlay?

Scan your site to see what issues the overlay isn't fixing. Free, 60 seconds.

Scan my website free →

How Much Does ADA Compliance Cost in 2026? →ADA Website Lawsuit: What Happens and How to Prevent It →